This is a marketing review for orthopedic administrators and marketing leads. It says nothing about clinical quality, and no practice is named.
Considering ongoing marketing support? I run orthopedic marketing agency services for practices like yours. I can discuss your priorities and possible scope. Fees, responsibilities, account access and handover terms are defined in a written proposal. Request a marketing review
Most orthopedic marketing reports count clicks on the appointment button. Few follow the click to the end. At the end of October 2026 I reviewed the appointment path on the websites of 23 independent orthopedic practices in 15 states, and wrote down where each patient would land.
Where the path ended
| Where the appointment path ended | Practices (of 23) |
|---|---|
| A request form or general contact form, with no booking | 10 |
| A phone number, email or fax, with no form at all | 5 |
| Something else I recorded separately | 8 |
I am not counting the eight in the third row here, so do not read the first two rows as the whole picture. My notes do not record a real-time scheduling screen on the appointment page of any of the 23. My automated check in the homepage study did find signs of online scheduling on 6 of 21 homepages, and some of those may be patient portals rather than booking.
What a patient meets along the way
A form that promises a reply later
One booking page promised a reply in 2 to 3 business days. Another labelled its page “Schedule Online” but said a staff member would contact the patient to confirm. These are honest, but a person comparing surgeons on a phone at night may not wait three days.
A page with no form
At one practice the online appointment page contained no form, only a request to call, and its Request Appointment link looped back to the same page. At another, appointment buttons all led to a contact page offering only phone numbers and an email address.
Links that do nothing
One contact page had an Email Office link under every location that had no destination. A patient who taps it gets nothing and may not try again.
A button nobody can find
One homepage had no appointment button at all. Another showed Schedule an Appointment only in a navigation dropdown and a sidebar, while the main buttons on the homepage went to information pages. A third placed its scheduling link below four long procedure descriptions.
Patients the form turns away
One practice’s request form could not be used for spine patients, hand therapy patients or some insurance plans, and told them to call. The page that most needs to work for those patients sends them to the phone.
What I would fix first
- Put one appointment button in the header, visible on every page and every screen size.
- Make the destination a real form with a short list of fields. Name, phone, the problem, preferred time. Ask for the rest after the patient has chosen you.
- Say exactly what happens next and when. A same-business-day reply beats a vague promise.
- Test every button and every Email link on a phone. This takes ten minutes and finds the dead ones.
- Offer an after-hours option. A callback request at 9 pm costs little to add. My guide to orthopedic online scheduling explains the options.
- Count the finished requests, not the clicks. Then follow each one to the first kept consult, as in my new-patient intake guide.
How I did this, and its limits
- Sample: 23 practices found through public web research. A hand-picked sample, not a random or national one.
- Method: I followed the appointment path from the homepage and the main service pages and recorded where it ended.
- What I did not measure: how many patients each gap costs, or how fast any practice replies. A practice may also have fixed a problem since I looked. See my study of 21 orthopedic homepages for the automated checks.
Want your appointment path checked?
I will record a short free walkthrough of your appointment path on a phone, with the fixes I would make first. You do not need a call to get it, and the fixes are yours to keep. Request a free audit.
